ICC prosecutor still struggling to implement new strategy

08 October 2014 by Janet H. Anderson, The Hague (The Netherlands)

A year ago this month, the International Criminal Court’s Office of the Prosecutor (OTP) presented a strategic plan dramatically changing its approach to investigations. The changes followed a series of humiliating defeats the office suffered at the confirmation of charges stage in various hearings. Thus, out went short, focused probes. In came in-depth, open-ended ones that could be revolutionary. And yet today, the OTP is still arguing for increased resources.

ICC prosecutor Fatou Bensouda. Copyright ICC-CPI/Flickr
Image caption: 
ICC prosecutor Fatou Bensouda. Copyright ICC-CPI/Flickr

To date, the OTP has investigated nine situations, resulting in requests for 31 arrest warrants or summonses. Judges have refused to confirm charges for five of the 15 individuals brought to court. The most dramatic failures concerned former Ivorian president Laurent Gbagbo and Callixte Mbarushimana, a Rwandan accused of atrocities in the Democratic Republic of Congo.

In the Gbagbo case, judges asked the OTP to return to the drawing board and find new evidence. “[T]he Prosecutor relied heavily on NGO reports and press articles with regard to key elements of the case,” they stated. But such documents “do not usually constitute a valid substitute for the type of evidence that is required to meet the evidentiary threshold for the confirmation of charges”. The prosecution was further accused of leaving an “incomplete picture” of the structural links between Gbagbo and the pro-Gbagbo forces alleged to have committed the crimes. This, back in June 2013, sent the OTP scrambling, though by June 2014, they had convinced the judges to proceed.

Want to read more?

We have tailor-made memberships for students, individuals, groups of professionals and large companies and organizations. A subscription entitles you to receive the International Justice Tribune every two weeks as well as become a member of the Justice Tribune Foundation, supporting independent reporting on international justice.

Subscribe now

Related articles

ICC prosecutor Fatou Bensouda addresses the UN Security Council in November 2015 (Photo: Flickr/IICC-CPI)
27 January 2016 by Janet H. Anderson, The Hague (The Netherlands)

IJT asked legal experts William Schabas and Evelyn Ankumah how they thought the ICC was doing and what remains needed. Schabas is optimistic and Ankumah shares a more reserved view. Both agree that the court must start showing it is not afraid to pursue alleged suspects from powerful states. 

08 October 2014 by Stephanie van den Berg

ICTR authorities in Kigali reacted with relief last week when the appeals chamber of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR) upheld genocide convictions in cases against three political leaders and an army official. 

08 October 2014

Links to articles and PDF of IJT issue 167.

08 October 2014 by Stephanie van den Berg

Lawyers for former Khmer Rouge leaders Khieu Samphan and Nuon Chea last week filed appeals against the life sentences that judges of the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC) issued in August for crimes against humanity.

The ICC presents its annual report to Assembly of States Parties in November 2015 (Photo: Flickr/ICC-CPI)
17 December 2015 by Benjamin Duerr, The Hague (The Netherlands)

In the face of financial and geopolitical realities and with several major judicial developments and administrative reforms coming up, 2016 could be a decisive year for the International Criminal Court (ICC).